What A Lexcel Mock Audit Actually Involves And Why The Pass Rate Matters
The question asked most often by Firm's considering a Lexcel application or re-accreditation is some version of: "How bad is it going to be?"
The honest answer is that it depends almost entirely on how prepared you are before the assessor arrives. And the best way to know how prepared you are is to go through the process once, with someone who has been through it many times, before the real thing.
What Lexcel is and what it assesses
The Law Society's Lexcel accreditation is a practice management standard for solicitors' firms and not-for-profit legal advice organisations. It is voluntary, which means the firms that hold it have chosen to demonstrate that their management systems meet a defined standard. For clients, that is a signal. For insurers, it is sometimes relevant. For the practice itself, the process of getting there is often as valuable as the accreditation.
A Lexcel assessment works through the standard section by section: client care, case management, file reviews, risk management, people management, supervision, and financial management. For each section, the assessor is looking for evidence that your firm's actual practice matches its documented systems. The standard does not prescribe how you do things. It requires that you do what you say you do, and that what you say you do is adequate.
That second part is important. A firm with a comprehensive policy manual and files that bear no relation to it will struggle. So will a firm whose files are well maintained but whose policies have never been written down. The assessment is looking for coherence between the two.
What a mock audit covers
A mock audit follows the same structure as a real Lexcel assessment. The process is the same. The questions are the same. The difference is what happens when a gap appears.
In a mock audit, a gap is a finding you can act on. You have time to revise the policy, close the file review backlog, update the supervision records, or fix whatever the assessment has surfaced. In the real assessment, a gap is a finding that goes into the report. Enough of them, or the wrong kind, and the accreditation is not awarded.
The mock audit's value is the gap between those two outcomes.
What firms typically find
The most common finding in a mock audit is not a catastrophic failure. It is a drift between documented systems and actual practice that nobody had noticed because nobody had looked. The supervision policy says monthly meetings. The records show quarterly, when people remembered. The file review procedure says all files reviewed within three months of opening. The log shows some files have not been touched since they were opened.
These are not signs that a firm is badly run. They are signs that a firm has been busy, which is every firm. Systems drift under pressure. The purpose of the mock audit is to measure the drift before the real assessment does.
Why the pass rate matters
I hold the Law Society Lexcel Consultant accreditation (with a 100% pass mark) on the training assessment. More relevantly, every assessment that I have prepared, has passed.
That record matters to me for one reason: it is evidence that the preparation process works. A mock audit that surfaces gaps is only useful if those gaps get closed before the real thing. The preparation process, done properly, takes a firm from wherever it is to wherever it needs to be. The pass rate follows from that, not from anything about the assessment itself.
How far in advance to start
The question I would push back on is "how much time do we have?" The right question is "how much drift are we carrying?" A firm with well-maintained systems and current documentation can move through a mock audit and close any findings in six to eight weeks. A firm that has let things slide for a few years needs longer.
If you are approaching a Lexcel assessment, either first application or re-accreditation, and you are not sure which of those descriptions fits your firm, that is exactly what the free health-check is designed to establish. No obligation, no commitment to a mock audit. Just an honest picture of where you are and what, if anything, needs attention before the process starts.
Ashley Barwick is a Fellow of the Chartered Institute of Legal Executives and a Law Society accredited Lexcel Consultant.
Comments